Criminal Lawyer

The Insanity Plea in a Criminal Defense Case

Posted by on Sep 18, 2017 in Criminal Laws, Criminal Lawyer | 0 comments

Imagine being a mother who returns home to find her child stabbed and dead in the master bedroom. Imagine being the child stripped of innocence and losing your life to a horrible act of violence. These unfortunate scenarios are a real-life horror story for a Naperville mother who killed her son and the girl she was taking care of at the time. She is currently pleading insanity in the case. According to interviews, the devil told her to do this and wanted to get revenge on her husband.

Chicago Tribune states a trial is set to begin for this Naperville woman who was accused of stabbing two young children to death, her son, and another young girl that she was taking care of. The courtroom proceeding will rely on dissenting opinions of her mental health during the incident. She will be charged with first-degree murder. Her criminal defense attorney will defend her with an insanity plea. The defense attorney refused to comment the day before trial, knowing it was important for the insanity plea to work. The mother has been held in custody since 2012.

The evening of the murder, the girl’s mother returned home from work and could not get in her home. She called the police and discovered a scene out of a horror movie. The detectives found the bodies of the two children in the master bedroom. They were stabbed multiple times and their throats were slashed. Robert Marshall, Chief Officer, commented that it was the bloodiest scene he had seen in his entire career. After the children died, the defendant was found at a Naperville home where she was staying with her other son. In the interview with the police, the mother took the children to church before returning home with them, where they would die. The children were in the master bedroom jumping up and down on the bed when she entered the room and told them to get on their knees and pray. She started stabbing the children as they were praying. She told the police she was hearing voices from the devil. The devil told her to save their souls by killing them. The woman also fought with her husband frequently and felt that she had to kill her son to get revenge on her him. Defense attorneys Resnick, the evaluator, and psychiatrist, is supposed to testify on her mental state during the trial.

While I validate the idea of an insanity plea, it is important to take care of each other and yourselves. The kids did not have a chance to protect themselves, so this incident is truly sad and unfortunate for all of those close to the situation.

Read More